* = Deceased
1819 - 1821: Lodge was operating as Terre Haute Lodge, U. D. (Under Dispensation)
1821 - 1835: Bi-annual Elections held every six months, at the stated meetings in June and December.
1835 - 1844: No surviving records; Lodge met sub-rosa.
1845-1870: Annual Elections held a the June stated meeting.
1870 - Present: Lodge Elections are held at the meeting next preceding the Feast of St. John the Evangelist (December 27th)